Two sides, one sale, two stories.
- 1
A content partner brings the shopper. An extension takes the sale.
The shopper arrives through a review and fills a basket. A pop-up's click lands last, and both publishers say the order is theirs.
$100M+
in sales Awin's soft-click rule protected for earlier partners in 2025, sending them $7.1M in commission.
Awin, Jul 2026(opens the source) - 2
The audits said everything was fine.
Researchers showed Honey honouring stand-down rules in full for suspected compliance testers, and ignoring them for ordinary shoppers.
Benjamin Edelman, Dec 2025(opens the source)7 of 8
networks in the PMA's comparison require extensions to stand down, and all eight say they audit them.
Performance Marketing Association, Jan 2026(opens the source) - 3
Then the networks had to act.
Within nine days in January 2026, Rakuten Advertising, impact.com and Awin removed or suspended Honey. It settled one question and left every merchant with another: who else is doing it?
PPC Land, Jan 2026(opens the source) - 4
Now merchants are pulling back.
Fewer US programmes allow toolbars and extensions than two years ago. Each merchant that tightens up takes its publishers' earnings with it.
Performance Marketing Association, Jul 2026(opens the source)88%
of US brands allowed toolbars and extensions in 2024. Fewer do in 2026.
Performance Marketing Association, Oct 2024(opens the source)
What most teams try
- You could side with the merchant. Cut the publisher's terms on a hunch and you may lose real demand, and a partner, with it.
- You could side with the publisher. Keep paying, and the merchant starts wondering what else in your reports is padded.
Or you could put the same record in both hands.
With the merchant's permission, Benson shows where the shopper arrived from, where the credit changed and the commission at stake, from real sessions rather than test accounts. If it's still disputed, the merchant blocks the pop-up for most shoppers with a holdout, and everyone reads the same result.




